Top 11 Musky Fishing Lures

Top 11 Musky Fishing Lures

In this post we will list the top 11 musky fishing lures. Muskellunge, or musky as they are known to most anglers, are apex predators. They are one of the largest growing freshwater fish. They lie in ambush, often times and weeds, and dart out and devour their helpless prey. However, musky are not at all easy to catch. They did not earn their nickname, “a fish of 10,000 casts” for no reason!

top 11 musky fishing lures

Here are the top 11 Musky fishing lures;

  • Mepps Musky Killer
  • Eppinger Daredevil
  • Booyah Pikee Spinnerbait
  • Musky Double Cowgirl
  • Whopper Plopper
  • Suick Thriller
  • Reef Hawg
  • Lixada Swimbait
  • #14 Rapala Shad Rap
  • Blitz Bite Jointed Minnow
  • #14 Rapala Husky Jerk

While musky can be taken by anglers using live bait, the majority do so using artificial lures. There are several reasons for this. Lures allow anglers to cover a lot of water. Conversely, anglers fishing with live bait sit in one spot for a fairly long period of time. Also, artificial lures will draw strike for reasons other than hunger. The musky may be aggravated, excited, annoyed, or even just curious and take a bait.

musky fishing tackle

Musky prefer a substantial meal. They do not feed often, and when they do they want enough to satisfy their hunger. Therefore, most of the best musky fishing lures are quite large. For the most part, musky feed on live bait fish such as suckers and yellow perch. Most lures are designed to mimic these bait fish. However some really just put out flash and vibration to attract musky.

Best musky fishing tackle

Anglers fishing for musky must use heavy tackle, there really is no alternative. There are a couple of reasons for this. First and foremost, musky get very large. Fish in the 40 inch to 50 inch range are not uncommon. Second, the lures that are used to catch them are large, bulky, and heavy. This requires stout tackle to efficiently cast them for hours at a time.

musky fishing

Most anglers opt for two-handed bait casting tackle. This really is the most effective rod and reel combination to use when casting heavy musky lures. These rigs also give the angler plenty of power when setting the hook and fighting a large fish. Heavy spinning tackle can certainly be used effectively, and many do so.

Heavy braided line in the 60 pound test class is generally spooled onto the reels. The heavy lures used will cast a long way, even with this heavier line. Braided line has no stretch, excellent sensitivity, and is more abrasion resistant than monofilament. Due to the mouthful of sharp teeth, anglers use a 12 inch steel leader in most situations.

Click this link to shop Amazon for a Lew’s baitcasting rod and reel

“Fishing Lido Key is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.”

Top 11 musky fishing lures

The list of top 11 musky fishing lures is given in no particular order. They fall into several categories, including spoons, spinners, jerk baits, soft plastic baits, and swim baits. All have proven themselves to be excellent musky fishing lures over the years. Most of these lures can be both cast and trolled.

1)  Mepps Musky Killer

The Mepps Musky Killer is aptly named! It is number one on our list of top X musky fishing lures. In terms of musky Lures, it is fairly light, coming in at a little less than an ounce. It is 7 inches long. The Mepps Musky Killer is a legend amongst veteran musky anglers. It will catch fish and just about every situation and in any location. It is large enough to attract trophy musky while being light enough to cast for hours at a time.

This is a very versatile lure. It can be fished on or near the surface or as deep as 10 feet. The Musky Killer can be cast or trolled. It will catch fish in all seasons as well. They come in a wide variety of color patterns to match the local forage. In the waning light of late afternoon, a gold blade with a brown and orange tail is a good all-around combination.

One great thing about the Musky Killer is that it is very easy to use. The blades rotate easily, putting out a lot of flash and vibration. All the angler does is cast out, allow it to sink to the desired depth, then reel it back in using a steady rhythmic retrieve. As with all fishing, angler should vary the speed until a productive pattern emerges.

Click this link to shop Amazon for Mepps Musky Killer spinners

2)  Eppinger Daredevil

The Eppinger Daredevil is another iconic fishing lure. While most anglers associate it with northern pike, is extremely effective on musky as well. Most anglers go with the 1 ounce size, which is about 3 3/4 inches long. Like the Mepps lure above, it is relatively light in terms of a musky lure. This makes it fairly easy to cast for a long period of time. Some may consider it a nuisance, but as an added bonus it will catch plenty of northern pike along the way.

best river fishing lures

These spoons have a lot of built in action, making them easy to use for most anglers. The lure is cast out and allowed to sink a few seconds, then reeled back in using a steady retrieve, with some twitches and pauses in between. Again, the retrieve should be varied until a bite occurs. It is fairly versatile, and can be used over submerged weed beds, along weed lines, and even deeper around structure breaks such as channel edges and points.

The old school red and white daredevil spoon has caught a lot of fish over the decades. It is still a good choice for musky today. However, some anglers have gone to some of the more modern colors and finishes. Silver is a good choice on sunny days while gold works best on cloudy days and under other low light conditions. It is a versatile and durable bait that should be in every musky anglers tackle box!

Click this link to shop Amazon for Eppinger Daredevil spoons

3)  Booyah Pikee Spinnerbait

The Booyah Pikee Spinnerbait is another very productive musky fishing lure. Again, this is a fairly light baits coming in at just over one half an ounce. This makes it a great choice for anglers who prefer to use spinning tackle or don’t have the stamina to cast a heavy lure all day long. Don’t let the size for you, it will catch plenty of trophy musky!

Most anglers choose models with bright colors. It has large blades which put out a lot of flash and vibration. This bait is specifically designed by Booyah for musky fishing, therefore it is a bit more durable than other baits made for bass and pike. It is a fairly easy lure to use with a ton of built in action. Steady retrieve’s work best in a can be worked throughout the entire water column. Spinner baits are also a bit more weedless than spoons and in line spinners, making them an excellent choice and heavier weeds.

Click this link to shop Amazon for Pikee Spennerbaits

4)  Musky Double Cowgirl

This bait made by Musky Mayhem is another excellent musky lure with a proven track record. It is very durable and built to last and is one of the best spinners for musky. It is number four on the list of top X musky fishing lures. This is an excellent bait for novice anglers as it has a ton of built in action and all that is required to catch fish is a slow steady retrieve.

top 11 musky fishing lures

This is a larger bait, coming in at around 10 inches long and weighing close to 3 ounces. The pair of blades put out a ton of flash and vibration, even at slower speeds. It is an excellent lure to try when the sun is out and the musky are a bit less aggressive. It is excellent when fished over and through submerged weed beds as well is around other cover such as sunken trees and submerged rock piles.

Click this link to shop Amazon for Musky Double Cowgirl lures

5)  Whopper Plopper

The Whopper Plopper is a relative newcomer to the fishing game, compared to some of these other old-school baits. However, it is extremely effective. This is a top water lure. It puts out a ton of commotion on the surface due to its concave face along with the action of the tail.

Best fishing lures in rivers

These baits are very effective at pulling fish out of deeper weed beds. It is an excellent choice in the summer time when water temperatures are a bit higher. The commotion of this bait will draw some heart stopping strikes! If there is one drawback to this lure, it is that it is not as durable as some others. However, this will not be an issue when a trophy musky grabs!

Click this link to shop Amazon for Whopper Plopper baits

6)  Suick Thriller

The Suick Thriller has been around almost a century. It truly is one of the original musky fishing lures and belongs in every serious musky anglers tackle box. It is a proven veteran still catches plenty of fish to this day. The Suick Thriller comes in several different sizes, ranging from 7 inches long to 10 inches long. Unlike some other lures, the Suick Thriller does not have much built in action, the angler must impart it to the lure.

This is basically a jerk bait. It is very effective when ripped through weed beds and is a very durable bait as well. It is perhaps not the best choice for novice anglers, as it does take a bit of practice to master the rhythmic retrieve that is required to catch fish. However, the effort put in to learn how to use this bait will pay off with trophy musky.

Click this link to shop Amazon for Suick Thriller lures

7)  Reef Hawg

The Reef Hawg is in the family of glide baits. They are not as popular as they used to be, but are still very effective. This lure is made to work deeper than some of the other lures listed above. They can be used for both casting and trolling and are a good choice in cooler months when there is less weed growth and the fish have moved a bit deeper.

8)  Lixada swimbait

This segmented, multi-jointed lure is a bit of a combination between a crank bait in a swim bait. These segments cause a to swim in a very lifelike manner. The bait sinks slow enough that it can be worked both near the surface and at deeper depths. It is a very durable bait with large, quality treble hooks.

In most instances, a slow steady retrieve a few feet below the surface works best. This is particularly true over submerged weed beds. The flash in action are astounding and this is a proven musky lure. This is a big bait, coming in at a full foot long and almost half a pound. Smaller versions of this lure are available, too.

Click this link to shop Amazon for Lixada swim baits

9)  #14 Rapala Shad Rap

This large crank bait is a very productive musky fishing lure that is popular with many anglers. It is a heavy bait and is effective when both cast and trolled. The yellow perch and fire tiger patterns work well. It has a lot of built in action. A slow steady retrieve with some hard jerks and pauses generally works best. Slow trolling with this bait is very effective in the wintertime.

Click this link to shop Amazon for Rapala Shad Rap lures

10) Blitz Bite Jointed Minnow

The Blitz Bite Jointed Minnow is another very lifelike swim bait style lure. Anglers can tell from the first glance at it is a quality bait. It is 8 inches long and weighs 3 ounces. Like most of these lures in this family, a slow steady retrieve works best. The lure will swim through the water in a very natural manner. The bait is made from plastic and is fairly durable, all things considered.

11)  #14 Rapala Husky Jerk

Rapala is the name in the industry when it comes to jerk baits. It is no exception when it comes to musky fishing as well. That is why the #14 Husky Jerk finishes off the list of the top 11 musky fishing lures. This is a long and slender bait that is fairly easy to cast and work all day. It comes in a variety of colors, with gold and fire tiger being proven finishes.

The key to the effectiveness of this lure is its ability to suspend in the water column. The angler retrieves the bait for a few feet then twitch is it hard followed by a pause. During this pause, the bait hangs there, seemingly motionless and helpless. This is often times when the fish attacks! It works well when either cast or troll. It also has a rattle and it as well.

Click this link to shop Amazon for Rapala Husky Jerk plugs

Musky fishing tips

While musky are certainly not easy to catch, there are a few tips which will help anglers be more successful. Part of the allure and satisfaction of musky fish and is understanding how difficult and challenging they are to catch. It was easy, anyone could do it! Most anglers consider musky fish in the pinnacle of cold water freshwater fishing.

Most anglers with any experience musky fishing know about the “figure 8” technique. Musky are famous for following a lure all the way to the boat but not eating. At the end of each cast, anglers put their rod tip in the water and with the lure a few feet behind do several figure eights in the water. It is amazing how many musky have been hooked right at the boat using this technique.

Another helpful tip is to concentrate musky fishing on the prime times. For whatever reason, musky do not seem to feed well in the morning. Therefore, there is no need to get up at the crack of dawn and cast for an extra six hours. It is best to concentrate musky fishing in the afternoon hours as the light wanes. Cloudy, drizzly days are good as well.

Many anglers combine musky fishing with some other type of fishing. For example, they might get up at first light and through top water plugs for bass, then switch to jigging the bottom for walleye mid-day. After a good lunch and a nap, they can then hit the water hard for musky. Most anglers simply can’t cast these big heavy lures all day long. Therefore, it is best to maximize the opportunity and concentrate on the prime fishing times.

In conclusion, this article on the top 11 musky fishing lures will help anglers catch more of these incredible freshwater game fish!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *